See all results →
Every company, graded Rankings by state & line Worst auto insurers Worst home insurers Worst health insurers Pet, motorcycle & other cover Compare two companies How to file a complaint How we grade Data sources

Every insurance company, graded

Consumer brands first — the names people actually buy from, with every licensed company they write through combined. Below them, the independent carriers that trade under their own name.

Brands

D

Erie Insurance

$400.5m premium written · 2 companies

—

Plymouth Rock

$217.0m premium written · 2 companies

C

MetLife

20,649,430 policies · 2 companies

A

Lincoln Financial

8,325,682 policies · 2 companies

A

Mutual of Omaha

7,767,716 policies · 2 companies

F

Cigna

7,669,175 policies · 7 companies

F

UnitedHealthcare

7,458,728 policies · 8 companies

F

Blue Cross Blue Shield

5,423,413 policies · 2 companies

F

Centene

4,635,680 policies · 6 companies

D

Prudential

3,856,787 policies · 2 companies

D

Globe Life

3,282,245 policies · 3 companies

D

Guardian Life

2,960,498 policies · 3 companies

B

Principal

2,725,567 policies · 2 companies

F

Aetna

1,890,446 policies · 9 companies

F

Transamerica

1,774,688 policies · 3 companies

F

Humana

1,641,158 policies · 8 companies

—

New York Life

1,387,342 policies · 3 companies

—

Northwestern Mutual

919,092 policies

B

Lemonade

682,162 policies

—

MassMutual

569,673 policies

—

Oscar Health

371,421 policies

—

Allianz

243,597 policies · 2 companies

—

Pacific Life

232,862 policies · 3 companies

C

Hippo

191,147 policies

C

Dairyland

154,940 policies · 2 companies

—

Molina

76,818 policies · 2 companies

D

Gainsco

73,890 policies

—

CNA

53,741 policies · 2 companies

—

Elephant

39,766 policies

—

Zurich

30,843 policies · 3 companies

—

Safeway Insurance

29,328 policies

—

Clearcover

25,470 policies

—

Berkshire Hathaway

20,947 policies · 5 companies

—

Root

5,264 policies

—

Westfield

3,101 policies · 2 companies

—

Hanover

2,934 policies · 2 companies

—

Selective

79 policies

A

Chubb

figures pending— · 10 companies

A

The Hartford

figures pending— · 10 companies

B

GEICO

figures pending— · 8 companies

C

State Farm

figures pending— · 3 companies

C

Progressive

figures pending— · 6 companies

—

Cincinnati Insurance

figures pending— · 2 companies

C

Farmers

figures pending— · 12 companies

C

Mercury Insurance

figures pending— · 2 companies

C

Amica

figures pending— · 2 companies

C

Travelers

figures pending— · 9 companies

C

Assurant

figures pending— · 2 companies

—

Stillwater

figures pending— · 2 companies

D

Allstate

figures pending— · 5 companies

D

Nationwide

figures pending— · 9 companies

D

Liberty Mutual

figures pending— · 8 companies

D

USAA

figures pending— · 3 companies

D

American Family

figures pending— · 5 companies

—

The General

figures pending— · 2 companies

F

AIG

figures pending— · 5 companies

—

Encompass

figures pending— · 5 companies

F

National General

figures pending— · 4 companies

—

Esurance

figures pending— · 2 companies

—

Kemper

figures pending— · 6 companies

Other graded carriers

F Lm General Insurance Company 1.68 $1.33bn
A New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company 0.38 $954.9m
A John Hancock Life Insurance Company (U.s.a.) 0.01 884,972,303
A Dearborn Life Insurance Company 0.14 6,774,089
A Vision Service Plan Insurance Company 0.13 6,717,152
A Unum Life Insurance Company Of America 0.20 6,496,891
A Life Insurance Company Of North America 0.44 6,113,082
A Cmfg Life Insurance Company 0.17 5,991,534
A John Hancock Life & Health Insurance Company 0.20 3,223,787
A Minnesota Life Insurance Company 0.39 2,761,281
B Sun Life Assurance Company Of Canada 0.52 2,629,152
A El Paso First Health Plans, Inc. 0.24 2,440,132
B Reliastar Life Insurance Company 0.45 2,176,266
B Standard Insurance Company 0.51 2,157,399
A Fidelity Security Life Insurance Company 0.30 2,141,323
A Clover Insurance Company 0.29 1,931,758
C Ameritas Life Insurance Corp. 0.85 1,691,590
D Redpoint County Mutual Insurance Company 1.40 1,397,117
F Celtic Insurance Company 20.50 1,175,381
D Continental American Insurance Company 0.97 1,089,522
B American Heritage Life Insurance Company 0.57 1,063,477
A Amerigroup Texas, Inc. 0.43 1,020,871
B Colonial Life And Accident Insurance Company 0.60 950,624
B Texas Children's Health Plan, Inc. 0.47 899,265
B Silverscript Insurance Company 0.49 827,093
C Asi Lloyds 0.67 784,760
F Home State County Mutual Insurance Company 1.84 714,671
F Old American County Mutual Fire Insurance Company 2.36 597,955
C Texas Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company 0.86 496,596
D Auto Club County Mutual Insurance Company 1.34 477,081
B Texas Farm Bureau Underwriters 0.45 455,989
B Texas Windstorm Insurance Association 0.45 442,493
C Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company 0.75 386,422
C Auto Club Indemnity Company 0.87 368,761
F Loya Insurance Company 5.94 342,820
C Germania Farm Mutual Insurance Association 0.65 315,485
F American Economy Insurance Company 1.63 288,257
B Texas Fair Plan Association 0.51 241,695
F Ranchers And Farmers Mutual Insurance Company 1.67 232,893
B American Modern Property And Casualty Insurance Company 0.57 184,087
B Texas Mutual Insurance Company 0.55 160,726
D American Mercury Lloyd's Insurance Company 1.16 160,585
F Infinity County Mutual Insurance Company 2.32 129,445
B Germania Select Insurance Company 0.45 122,938
B Texas Farm Bureau Casualty Insurance Company 0.55 112,502
F Goauto Insurance Company 2.32 110,626
D American Access Casualty Company 1.21 108,695
B Hochheim Prairie Farm Mutual Insurance Association 0.48 104,700
B Toggle Insurance Company 0.49 99,034
D Falcon Insurance Company 1.32 98,924
C Alinsco Insurance Company 0.90 98,766
C Trumbull Insurance Company 0.82 88,947
F Tesla Property & Casualty, Inc. 14.85 82,953
A Essentia Insurance Company 0.36 —
A American Modern Home Insurance Company 0.39 —
D Farmers Property And Casualty Insurance Company 1.16 —
D American States Insurance Company 1.48 —
D Garrison Property And Casualty Insurance Company 1.52 —