New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company in New York

The New York Department of Financial Services confirmed 5 complaints against New York Central Mutual Fire Insurance Company on $954.9m premium written of business — a complaint index of 0.38 against a New York market average of 1.00.

By type of insurance in New York

Coverage	Grade	Index	Complaints	Business written
Auto insurance	A	0.38 62% below market raw 0.17	5	$954.9m
All lines	A	0.38 62% below market raw 0.17	5	$954.9m

Least complained-about insurers in New York

Ranked on the same measure. This is a complaint record, not a recommendation — price, coverage and claim outcomes are not measured here.

A GEICO 0.31 A Nationwide 0.26 B The Hartford 0.82 B Progressive 0.92 C State Farm 0.96

Where these figures come from

New York State Department of Financial Services — Automobile Insurance Company Complaint Rankings (2009–2024) · retrieved 27 Aug 2026

Figures cover 2023–2025. Grades are rebuilt when regulators publish new files.